Feedback P&A Ceremony

The Deputy Commander UF Starfleet assists the office of the Commander in Chief with the overall direction of UFS.

Moderator: Kermie Mistwallow

What option would you choose?

Continue as Normal
24
55%
More Formal
19
43%
Something Else
1
2%
 
Total votes: 44
User avatar
Kermie Mistwallow
Command - Admiral
Command - Admiral
Posts: 3091
Joined: 081121.1030
Duty Post: Deputy CinC, UF Starfleet
Ship/Station Posted: Headquarters
Grid: Second Life
Location: England, United Kingdom
Has thanked: 53 times
Been thanked: 621 times
Contact:

220531.0546

I am looking for feedback regarding the Promotions and Awards Ceremony held each month to celebrate the success of our members.

The topic has been addressed with the Joint Chiefs and rather us make the decision to change we want you to choose what you prefer.

The options are

Continue as normal - For those that like to have the humour, charges read (reason for promotion), Guilty pleas and punishment (all done in fun) select that option.

Change to More Formal - this would simply be reading off the reason for the promotion and the promotion itself

Something Else - email to joint.chiefs@ufstarfleet.org or IM one of the JC's
Admiral
Deputy Commander in Chief
User avatar
Drewski Northman
Command - Captain
Command - Captain
Posts: 366
Joined: 200127.0120
Duty Post: Commanding Officer
Ship/Station Posted: USS Atlas
Grid: Second Life
Location: US- Midwest
Has thanked: 129 times
Been thanked: 101 times
Contact:

220531.0600

So, I wanted to add a bit of explanation to my vote. I hope its not inappropriate to share some additional thoughts here.

I voted to keep the humor and lighter aspects, but I think as everything in life, it should be balanced. As with all comedy, there’s a fine line that can be crossed if you’re not careful. If I were 100% honest, I think the line was crossed a bit on Saturday. There were several points where I was inwardly cringing, and I usually don’t during the P&A. So, do I want us to be able to enjoy the ceremony and have a good time with it and be able to laugh as well as celebrate the achievements of our friends. BUT I think we should be careful not to go too overboard. I hope that makes sense.
In Service,

Captain Drewski Northman
CO, USS Atlas NCC 74138
Branch Commander: UFS Science
User avatar
Ulrich Bechir
Intelligence - Captain
Intelligence - Captain
Posts: 211
Joined: 220519.0750
Duty Post: Intelligence
Ship/Station Posted: USS Atlas
Grid: Second Life
Location: London, Ontario, Canada
Has thanked: 106 times
Been thanked: 241 times
Contact:

220531.0617

I voted for more formal myself. While I understand that humour can be very nice, I think there is a possibility to go overboard, even if by accident. We're all guilty of it sometimes. As we don't necessarily know the tolerances of another person for what I know is supposed to be teasing, I think it might just be better to avoid it. This is a huge venue with lots of people in it, this means that if the person feels embarrassment or humiliation it is magnified greatly compared to other venues. Perceptions about power dynamic could also effect this. Finally, I believe it also has to be remembered that we are supposed to be celebrating the recipient, not entertaining the crowd. If the person feels uncomfortable then we haven't really honoured them well.

These, of course, are my views. I can live with whatever is decided and I fully respect Drew's point of view.

In Service,

CMDR Ulrich Bechir
INTEL Officer, USS Veracruz
Last edited by Ulrich Bechir on 220531.0723, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Bodan Resident
Security - Captain
Security - Captain
Posts: 194
Joined: 110611.1550
Duty Post: Chief Security Officer
Ship/Station Posted: Denkiri CC
Grid: 3rd Rock Grid
Location: United Kingdom
Has thanked: 97 times
Been thanked: 127 times
Contact:

220531.0641

I voted for more formal, not that it matters to me as I can hardly ever make it to UFS stuff on Saturday's, hence my absence for my own this Saturday just gone. I kind of agree with the two previous posts though, I think the humour can easily be misinterpreted especially as its delivered in written form.
Captain Bodan Landar
Starfleet Security
Denkiri Station
:flags-wavegreatbritain:
User avatar
Lizzy Gracemount
Medical - Commodore
Medical - Commodore
Posts: 473
Joined: 160518.1957
Duty Post:
Ship/Station Posted: Pinastri Headquarters
Grid: Second Life
Location: Idaho
Has thanked: 152 times
Been thanked: 120 times
Contact:

220531.0651

The humor is my favorite part. It creates a lighter mood and helps me forget my reality for a while.
“You never know how strong you are until being strong is the only choice you have.” —Bob Marley

"Set course for Relay, Warp Factor 9!" ~ Kermie

“A man either lives life as it happens to him, meets it head-on and licks it, or he turns his back on it and starts to wither away.” –Dr. Boyce, “The Menagerie,” (“The Cage”)

“Logic is the beginning of wisdom, not the end.” – Mr. Spock, Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country
RodneyMMckay
Medical - Captain
Medical - Captain
Posts: 381
Joined: 150623.1721
Duty Post: Medical
Ship/Station Posted: USS Veracruz
Grid: SL
Location: NYC
Has thanked: 26 times
Been thanked: 34 times

220531.0737

I agree with Lizzy. Some people take rank way too seriously. The humor is a way to remind them that this is supposed to be fun.
CMO USS Veracruz
Senior Medical Advisor, UFS
User avatar
Ferre Flamand
Sciences - Lieutenant
Sciences - Lieutenant
Posts: 366
Joined: 211111.0543
Duty Post: Vice Chief Science Officer
Ship/Station Posted: SS Tranquility
Grid: Second Life
Location: Belgium
Has thanked: 194 times
Been thanked: 56 times
Contact:

220531.0838

I have also opted to leave everything as it is. Humor should be possible, although not everyone's humor is of the same caliber. As long as it doesn't turn into some downright vaudeville which I don't think will happen anytime soon. It struck me, the first time I experienced it, positively that it was given a humorous swing :)
Vice Chief Science Officer
SS Tranquility
User avatar
Siobhan Crystal
Command - Commander
Command - Commander
Posts: 321
Joined: 101226.1642
Duty Post: Executive Officer
Ship/Station Posted: USS Atlas
Grid: SecondLife
Location: Oregon
Has thanked: 36 times
Been thanked: 28 times
Contact:

220531.1519

A highlight, for me, of the P&A ceremony is the humor. Ceremony is fine, but to just hand out an award without a personal touch is something that can be done by mail. To actually take the time to show the recipient you care enough to acknowledge them in a personal manner, other than a cold statement and a handshake (virtual), means far more to me than another pip or a ribbon.
Image

"Outside a dog, a book is man's best friend. Inside a dog, it's too dark to read." --- Groucho Marx

Access Service Jacket
Greg Esharham
Engineering - Commander
Engineering - Commander
Posts: 150
Joined: 091109.1403
Duty Post: Director Star fleet Event
Ship/Station Posted: Chief Engineer Denkiri Center
Grid: Second Life/3rd Rock
Location: Melbourne Australia
Has thanked: 59 times
Been thanked: 51 times
Contact:

220531.2036

While I would say I would prefer the ceremony to be more aligned with a formal Military based ceremony ( Not forgetting that Roddenberry did base the system of Star Fleet on the US Navy ) I don't mind the humor, this whole thing is supposed to be a bit of fun. Just as long as it's not disrespectful.

I would suggest we do add change of command ceremonies and hand over for ships, stations and command positions as well to the monthly P & A. This would make it easier for the Members to follow who are in these positions as sometimes single announcements can be missed and it is nice to know.

There are not many I doubt it would add more than a few Minutes.

I rarely make them ( even my own due to time zone ) although I would like to, but I do read back the whole thing most times for a couple of reasons to stay informed and to see who the recipients are to congratulate them specifically those I know personally.
Access Service Jacket

Image

“There are people who make things happen, there are people who watch things happen, and there are people who wonder what happened. To be successful, you need to be a person who makes things happen..” James A. Lovell US Astronaut, Gemini 7, Gemini 12, Apollo 8, Apollo 13
User avatar
Amcruising Resident
Operations - Ensign
Operations - Ensign
Posts: 166
Joined: 210904.0419
Duty Post: Operations
Ship/Station Posted: Pinastri Headquarters
Grid: Second Life
Has thanked: 75 times
Been thanked: 38 times
Contact:

220531.2243

I voted for formal simply as that was the way it was in the Royal NZ Navy.
Ensign Amanda Cruisier
Operations Officer
UFSA Mentor, Starfleet Academy
Keitha02 Resident
Sciences - Commander
Sciences - Commander
Posts: 68
Joined: 200630.0654
Duty Post: Science Officer
Ship/Station Posted: USS Sheppherd
Grid: Second Life
Location: England
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 19 times

220601.0113

continue as normal
Image
Oola Quan
Operations - Lt Commander
Operations - Lt Commander
Posts: 29
Joined: 210228.0726
Duty Post:
Ship/Station Posted:
Grid:
Has thanked: 38 times
Been thanked: 9 times

220601.0121

I like the normal one, though I must admit I miss Kermie's punishments. I did enjoy them
Image
MilesPrower Dagger
Command - Fleet Admiral
Command - Fleet Admiral
Posts: 2377
Joined: 081104.0908
Duty Post: Deputy Commander, UF Starfleet
Ship/Station Posted: UFS HQ
Grid: Unknown
Location: Virgnina
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 445 times

220601.0922

I can see both sides, it really depends on your experiences. The funny one comes from Generations and I think it works well when its personalized and with friends but I can also see people wanting it to be more formal. There isn't a right answer to me.
User avatar
David7 Bravin
Science - Commodore
Science - Commodore
Posts: 1621
Joined: 110730.0809
Duty Post: Chief Science Officer
Ship/Station Posted: Denkiri Starbase UFS Astraios
Grid: 3rd Rock Grid
Location: England, UK
Has thanked: 52 times
Been thanked: 84 times
Contact:

220602.0328

I have voted for "More Formal" because amongst other things, the P&A Ceremony should be to recognise and praise those members who have worked hard to be promoted and to celebrate their achievements. Their hard work should NOT to be regarded as a "crime" and the reasons for their promotion being read out as "charges" for which they are expected to plead "guilty" and then be given stupid "punishments".
Although some may regard this as "fun" - it may not be for the individual on the receiving end, especially if others present at the P&A ceremony join in by adding their comments.

The "Change to More Formal" does not have to "simply be reading off the reason for the promotion and the promotion itself" - it can be more. 

Commodore David7 Bravin
Denkiri Starbase
UFS Astraios Colony
Astraios Alpha Company Graduate 110830
Access Service Jacket
User avatar
Michel Farrell
UFS Civilian
UFS Civilian
Posts: 51
Joined: 140924.1310
Duty Post: Operations Officer
Ship/Station Posted: SS Astraios
Grid: 3rd Rock Grid
Location: Leidschendam, Netherlands
Been thanked: 1 time
Contact:

220602.0401

I have voted for "More formal" . Ceremonies like this are serious business in my eyes, not a place for this "Crime" and "Punish" jokes. How would you think a new member that just graduated as an Ensign and attending de P&A ceremony for the very first time will look at this? Maybe he/she gets a wrong impression of UFS.
Post Reply

Return to “Deputy CinC, UF Starfleet”